1940s Fashion – The American Look vs Dior 1947

Paris Fashion Rises Again  –

Model-wears--dior-dress--1948-robert-capa

Photo taken by the Seine in Paris 1948 of a model sporting a Christian Dior dress. These early frocks were reputed to be quite heavy and cumbersome

After virtual domination for some years by the Americans, there is no better way to sum up the new post-war Paris fashion explosion, and the panic and incredulity which it triggered, than in this defensive, though admittedly accurate, fashion review from 1947 procured from that great archaeologist of all things papery – Old Magazine Articles.

1940s-post-war-fashion---America-vs-Paris

1940s-post-war-fashion—America-vs-Paris

Paris and Hollywood were never farther apart than they are in this, the second year of the atomic age. Hollywood, paced by Adrian and Paris – under the magic spell of Dior, have their lines clearly established in the current battle of the silhouette, or should we say – bulges !
Unlike most wars, the women of 1947 cannot lose. What they lack in figure, they can now recover in fashion, thanks to the Haute Couture of Mister Gilbert Adrian and Monsieur Christian Dior.

Actually the apposing lines were not drawn, nor sewn, solely in an effort to capture the world’s fashion leadership. They were inspired by distinctly different cultures, and reflect, in amazing degree, both the position of women and the economic stability of postwar France and postwar America!

The American Look

1940s-Fashion---The-American-Look-vs-Diors-'New-Look-'-1947

Feminine tailoring from Dior or Adrian

Gilbert Adrian, for instance, holds the feminine figure of America, like its truths, to be self evident, and not in need of padding. He confines his exaggeration for the most part, therefore, to the shoulders. the feminine silhouette, as he sees it, has widened shoulders, a slim waist, and slim hips. The American woman is strictly Twentieth Century, streamlined, smooth, svelte. ” I feel very much the need of doing clothes that will fit into the wonderful new architecture .” he said in a recent Vogue interview.

rita-hayworth--1947--Jean-Louis

Rita Hayworth models in a promotional photogrpah for Orson Welles movie The Lady from Shanghai in 1947 – designer Jean-Louis

“Contemporary clothes for a fast-moving century, clothes that are part of the life that women lead today”
Adrian’s casualness, evident in all his styles, is borne of the self confidence of the American woman, postwar edition. She knows that her country is looked to as the world leader.

L-Aiglon-Frock-1948--Frances-McLaughlin-Gill

Philadelphia label L’Aiglon-Frock-1948–Frances-McLaughlin-Gill

She knows that her government is the most democratic and, potentially, the most acceptable in the world. And she knows that her society enjoys the finest and the free-est. Adrian provides the style that expresses this unpretentious comfort.

1940s-Fashion---The-American-Look-vs-Diors-'New-Look-'-1947b

Adrian – summer evening dress 1947

Since the American woman’s design for living is never fixed nor dogmatic, but always in step with changing conditions, Adrian modifies his basic lines wherever the design can be improved by extra yardage. If more material adds grace and meaning to a dress, he will drape the skirts, add a cape, or borrow the lines from the Japanese to make a blouse blowsier.

Three-Dresses---Adrian-1947

This is a formidable fashion strategy, and one that can hardly be intimidated by the new Parisian designs. Adrian and his followers are made of sturdy stuff, and they will not retreat because their Paris contemporaries, bolstered, indeed by a few new York disciples, drop the bulge from the shoulder and place it on the hips!

The Paris New Look of 1947.

dior-model-renee-in--the-bar-suit-of-1947-b

Diors Famous 1947 Bar Suit Close Up – Met Museum

Howard Greer, upon returning from Paris found Diors ‘ New Look’ to be distorting, extreme, exaggerated, and entirely contrary to the American figure, taste, and active way of life”
“In dressing women” he said, ” I find that slim hips are definitely preferred”.
This again partially explains the diametrically apposed trends in Paris-Hollywood fashions. here, there is plenty to eat, and the worry is that hips ‘ may’ get out of line. In Paris, the problem ( among many) is food, and the best way for it, is to add a few yards on a woman’s derriere.

Paris-fashion-1948--mark-kauffman
Christian Dior, who seems to have appropriated the fashion rostrum in Paris and decrees decor at will, spins the feminine figure in the unconventional manner, trying to make her look good where she ain’t. He seeks the ballet dancer illusion – natural, rounded shoulders, too weak to support a struggling world, a natural calling to the perplexed women of postwar France.

1949---Balmain-suit---Clifford-Coffin

1949—Balmain-suit—Clifford-Coffin

Her waist is pinched in an exaggerated indentation, the better to emphasise her padded hips. Since Dior opened his new house in February, he has continued to startle the couture world with a frenetic use of frou-frou. There are butterfly sleeves, box pockets, belled jackets, and barrelled skirts, suggesting something like a Gibson Girl, or whatever grandmother should have worn. He continues with other exaggerations – mad tunics, tier upon tier of back draping, swirls, pleats, and dips that recall a France in gay, flirtatious days, when she could afford to be extravagant.

Dior-model-wearing-New-Look-long-skirt--1948

Dior-model-wearing-New-Look-long-skirt–1948

Of the two, Adrian is far more realistic, far more representative of his environment [ for example – the modern home, and workplace ]. Dior tries to revive the glory of France, and for this he should be commended. But his elaborate fashions are beyond the reach of many in Paris; he must have his New York followers. he has a few. Unencumbered by slim silhouette demands from the O.P.A, there are New York designers who are indulging in more drapery. They are dropping hemlines ( the big battle ahead) and adding a puff or a pocket. But this is a natural largess bursting out after wartime repression. Allay any qualms which might arise from the ‘ liberation’ of the American fashion libido. US women have found a new expression in dress, and they will not retreat to the bustle and cinched girdles of yesteryear.’

This was written in 1947. By 1953, women all over America had taken to the New Look, cinched waists and girdles included!

That’s all !
©Glamourdaze 2016
Originally published by Rob Wagners Script 1947

Read the Concise Illustrated History of 1940s Fashion – 1940 to 1949

history-of-1940s-womens-fashion-banner5

Comments

  1. Great post. I’m a big Dior fan and I love Adrian’s work. It’s rather interesting to see both concepts face to face and how Adrian’s creations reflected a time of peace and stability, almost like a reassurance that everything was back on the tracks of normality whilst Dior had an edge and modernity, he was eager to start a new era and put the terrible reality of war behind. France suffered horribly during the war, the past wasn’t comforting, future was the only way left.